Tear by Erica McKeen was a book I didn’t know much about before deciding to read, aside from the unsettling description on the back promising an exploration of isolation and womanhood, and the image on the front cover that has stuck with me since I first saw it. This book was reminiscent of works by Mary Shelley, Daphne Du Maurier, and Shirley Jackson, echoing each of these storytellers in different ways, yet was undoubtedly something its own.
In this novel, we follow Frances, a young woman in her final year of university in London, Ontario. Frances is reserved, her existence so quiet in her basement bedroom that the three roommates above her often forget that she inhabits the rental house too. Only occasionally coming upstairs for food, Frances finds herself spending more and more time in the basement, until the musty air and dim atmosphere become almost inextricable from herself; until one day, or night, as she can no longer tell the difference, she makes her way up the basement stairs to find the door locked. Around the same time, she starts hearing a tapping noise coming from behind one of the walls, as incessant and pervasive as the “thick, physical” dark surrounding her at all times. Memories of Frances’ childhood start surfacing while she’s in the basement, of an adolescence marred by abandonment, yet also home to piercing moments of love and friendship. Down in the basement, we join Frances as she grapples with her own existence, as well as becoming company to whatever it is that keeps tapping behind the wall.
This book deals with memory, identity, and reality, the writing pulling you into Frances’ disorienting, tangled thoughts whether you want it to or not. At times, I honestly felt like I was questioning my reality right along with her, and I think that speaks to how immersive and unshakeable the author’s writing is. The places this book went really surprised me, and ended up being such a unique, unforgettable story for me. Repressed rage and the female experience were key themes of the book, and it really made me ponder the differences in how emotions and trauma are handled and accepted by society among men and women.
I thought the horror elements in this book were incredible, both in the creeping, dread inducing atmosphere as well as the moments of more shocking gore and violence. I think that Tear utilizes horror in such an effective, intentional way. I thought this book was so dynamic, and really offered a lot of different kinds of horror. Some of the imagery and scenes will stick with me and haunt me for a long time.
This book made me think so much, had me clinging to this story and attempting to untangle the layers and symbolism long after I turned the final page. I absolutely love when a book can linger with me as much as this one did. When I picked up this book, I was not prepared to be caught in the claws of something so dark and unrelenting, something that forces the reader to confront the shadowed parts of themselves typically confined to cobwebbed corners. I can certainly understand how this book may not be for everyone, but I really adored it and would love to see it get more recognition. Tear is a suffocating, mind-bending novel examining identity, adolescence, and what to do with the ghosts of our childhoods once we grow up.